The Greatest "Mystery, New York" Books of All Time

Click to learn how this list is calculated.

This list represents a comprehensive and trusted collection of the greatest books. Developed through a specialized algorithm, it brings together 300 'best of' book lists to form a definitive guide to the world's most acclaimed books. For those interested in how these books are chosen, additional details can be found on the rankings page.

Filter by: Genres Dates Countries
Follow on:

Genres

Mystery

The Mystery genre is a category of books that typically involves a crime, puzzle, or enigma that needs to be solved by the protagonist or a group of characters. These books often feature suspenseful and thrilling plotlines, with unexpected twists and turns that keep readers engaged and guessing until the very end. Mystery novels can range from cozy mysteries, which are lighter and more lighthearted, to hard-boiled detective stories, which are darker and more gritty. Overall, the Mystery genre is a popular and diverse category of books that appeals to readers who enjoy solving puzzles and uncovering secrets.

New York

The "New York" category of books typically refers to literature that is set in or explores the city of New York. These books may focus on the city's history, culture, and landmarks, or they may delve into the lives of its diverse inhabitants. From gritty crime novels to romantic comedies, the "New York" category encompasses a wide range of genres and styles, all united by their connection to one of the world's most iconic cities. Whether you're a native New Yorker or a curious outsider, these books offer a unique glimpse into the heart of the Big Apple.

Add additional genre filters

Countries

Date Range

Filter

Reading Statistics

Click the button below to see how many of these books you've read!

Download

If you're interested in downloading this list as a CSV file for use in a spreadsheet application, you can easily do so by clicking the button below. Please note that to ensure a manageable file size and faster download, the CSV will include details for only the first 500 books.

Download
  1. 1. The Complete Tales and Poems of Edgar Allan Poe by Edgar Allan Poe

    This collection brings together all of the author's most famous works, including poems, short stories, and novellas. Known for his macabre and gothic storytelling, the author's works are filled with themes of death, love lost, and human frailty. Notable inclusions are the haunting poem "The Raven," the chilling stories "The Tell-Tale Heart" and "The Fall of the House of Usher," and his only complete novel, "The Narrative of Arthur Gordon Pym."

  2. 2. The Talented Mr. Ripley by Patricia Highsmith

    The Talented Mr. Ripley is a psychological thriller that follows the story of Tom Ripley, a young man struggling to make ends meet in New York City. When a wealthy shipbuilder mistakes Tom for a close friend of his son, Dickie Greenleaf, he offers him an all-expenses-paid trip to Italy to persuade his wayward son to return home. Instead, Tom becomes obsessed with the luxurious lifestyle of Dickie and his girlfriend, Marge, and goes to extreme lengths to make it his own, including identity theft and murder.

  3. 3. The Godfather by Mario Puzo

    The book revolves around the powerful Italian-American crime family of Don Vito Corleone. When the don's youngest son, Michael, reluctantly joins the mafia, he becomes involved in the inevitable cycle of violence and betrayal. Although Michael tries to maintain a normal relationship with his wife, Kay, he is drawn deeper into the family business. The narrative follows the Corleone family's struggle to hold onto power in a rapidly changing world, as well as Michael's transformation from reluctant family outsider to ruthless mafia boss.

  4. 4. The New York Trilogy by Paul Auster

    "The New York Trilogy" is a collection of three detective stories that explore the nature of identity and the search for meaning. The stories are set in New York City and feature various characters, including a detective, a writer, and a professor, who are all engaged in their own personal quests. These quests often involve elements of mystery, existentialism, and introspection, and the stories are interconnected in various ways, creating a complex and thought-provoking narrative.

  5. 5. The Thin Man by Dashiell Hammett

    This detective novel follows a retired private investigator, Nick Charles, who, while on a Christmas vacation in New York with his wife Nora, becomes embroiled in a murder investigation. The case involves a former client of his, Clyde Wynant, who has mysteriously disappeared after his secretary was found dead. As the investigation unfolds, Nick and Nora navigate a complex web of deceit, lies, and family drama, all while maintaining their witty banter and high-society lifestyle.

  6. 6. Time and Again by Jack Finney

    Time and Again is a science fiction novel that follows Simon Morley, a young advertising artist living in New York City, who is recruited by a secret government project to travel back in time to the year 1882. The novel explores themes of nostalgia, love, and the complexity of time travel, as Simon falls in love with a woman from the past and must decide whether to stay in the 19th century or return to his own time.

  7. 7. Gone Girl by Gillian Flynn

    This thrilling novel revolves around the sudden disappearance of a woman on her fifth wedding anniversary. As the investigation unfolds, all evidence points to her husband as the prime suspect. However, the story takes a twist as the wife's diary entries reveal a darker side to their seemingly perfect marriage. The narrative alternates between the husband's present-day perspective and the wife's diary entries, leaving readers in suspense about what truly happened. The book explores themes of deceit, media influence, and the complexities of marriage.

  8. 8. The Leavenworth Case by Anna Katharine Green

    "The Leavenworth Case" is a gripping detective novel that follows the investigation of a wealthy man's murder. When the head of the Leavenworth family is found dead in his locked study, suspicion falls on his niece, who stands to inherit his fortune. As the evidence against her mounts, a brilliant young lawyer is determined to uncover the truth and prove her innocence. With twists and turns at every corner, this thrilling mystery keeps readers guessing until the final page.

  9. 9. The First Deadly Sin by Lawrence Sanders

    In this gripping crime novel, a seasoned New York City detective is on the brink of retirement when he's drawn into a challenging and high-stakes investigation. The city is terrorized by a series of brutal murders, each victim found with a small, mysterious token left by the killer. As the detective delves deeper into the case, he must navigate a complex web of clues and confront his own personal demons, all while racing against time to stop the methodical murderer before they strike again. The novel combines a gritty police procedural with psychological depth, exploring the nature of obsession and the cost of justice.

  10. 10. Blind Man with a Pistol by Chester Himes

    In the heart of Harlem, a blind man shoots his pistol aimlessly, setting off a series of chaotic events. Two detectives are tasked with investigating the resulting crimes, which include a restaurant bombing and a murder. The narrative is filled with dark humor, social commentary, and vivid descriptions of Harlem life, as the detectives navigate the complexities of their community and the absurdity of their situation.

  11. 11. A Rage In Harlem by Chester Himes

    This novel is a gripping tale set in the vibrant yet tumultuous streets of Harlem, where intrigue and danger lurk around every corner. It follows the desperate and chaotic journey of a man, deeply in love, as he navigates the dark underbelly of the city in an attempt to recover a fortune that he believes will win back the heart of his beloved. Along the way, he encounters a cast of characters as colorful and unpredictable as the neighborhood itself, including con men, crooked cops, and a femme fatale who is as dangerous as she is alluring. This story masterfully combines elements of crime, noir, and black humor, offering a vivid and unflinching look at life in mid-20th century Harlem.

  12. 12. The Alienist by Caleb Carr

    Set in 1896 New York City, the novel follows a journalist and his friend, a psychologist (or "alienist"), as they work on an investigation into a series of gruesome murders of boy prostitutes. The team employs psychological profiling and early forensic methods to hunt down the serial killer. The book delves into the seedy underbelly of the city, exploring the grim realities of life at the time.

  13. 13. The Conjure Man Dies by Rudolph Fisher

    "The Conjure Man Dies" is a captivating mystery set in 1930s Harlem, where a prominent African American physician is found dead in his home. As the police investigate, a cast of intriguing characters emerges, including a voodoo priest, a cunning detective, and a journalist determined to uncover the truth. With its rich portrayal of the vibrant Harlem Renaissance and a complex web of secrets and motives, this novel delves into race, class, and the supernatural, keeping readers guessing until the final page.

  14. 14. The League Of Frightened Men by Rex Stout

    In this gripping mystery, a brilliant and eccentric private detective is hired to address the fears of a group of men who believe they are being targeted by someone seeking revenge for a prank gone wrong years ago, which resulted in a tragic accident. As members of the group begin to meet untimely ends under mysterious circumstances, the detective uses his unique intellect and unconventional methods to unravel a complex web of guilt, deception, and murder. Set against the backdrop of New York City, the story combines psychological intrigue with the detective's sharp wit and profound insights into human nature, leading to a surprising resolution that challenges the concepts of justice and retribution.

  15. 15. The Tragedy Of Y by Ellery Queen

    "The Tragedy Of Y" by "Ellery Queen" is a gripping murder mystery set in a small town. The story follows the investigation led by detective Ellery Queen as he tries to unravel the truth behind the mysterious death of a prominent local figure. With a web of secrets, multiple suspects, and unexpected twists, Queen must navigate through a complex puzzle to uncover the shocking truth behind the tragedy.

  16. 16. Phantom Lady by Cornell Woolrich

    "Phantom Lady" is a gripping noir thriller that follows Scott Henderson, a man wrongfully accused of his wife's murder. With no alibi and no witnesses to vouch for him, Scott's only hope lies in finding the mysterious woman he met at a bar on the night of the crime. As he delves deeper into the dark underbelly of New York City, Scott uncovers a web of deception, danger, and hidden motives, all while racing against time to prove his innocence and bring the real killer to justice.

  17. 17. The Tragedy Of X by Ellery Queen

    "The Tragedy Of X" by "Ellery Queen" is a gripping mystery novel that follows the investigation of a puzzling murder case. When a renowned scientist is found dead in his laboratory, his death appears to be a suicide. However, detective Ellery Queen suspects foul play and begins to unravel a complex web of secrets and deceit. As the truth slowly emerges, Queen uncovers shocking revelations that challenge everything he thought he knew about the case, leading to a startling and unexpected conclusion.

  18. 18. The Greek Coffin Mystery by Ellery Queen

    "The Greek Coffin Mystery" by "Ellery Queen" is a thrilling detective novel that follows the renowned detective Ellery Queen as he investigates the baffling murder of a wealthy Greek art collector. Set in New York City, Queen must unravel a complex web of clues, hidden motives, and eccentric characters in order to solve the perplexing case. With his sharp intellect and keen observational skills, Queen navigates through a series of twists and turns, leading readers on an exciting journey filled with suspense and intrigue.

  19. 19. The Egyptian Cross Mystery by Ellery Queen

    In "The Egyptian Cross Mystery," a wealthy man is found dead in his locked study, with a mysterious Egyptian cross lying beside him. As Ellery Queen investigates the puzzling circumstances surrounding the murder, he uncovers a web of secrets, hidden identities, and a complex plot that leads him to a thrilling and unexpected conclusion. With a blend of intricate puzzles, suspenseful twists, and a dash of Egyptian mythology, this gripping mystery keeps readers guessing until the very end.

  20. 20. Bank Shot by Donald E. Westlake

    In this comedic crime caper, a motley crew of thieves concocts an audacious plan to steal a bank. Rather than attempting a traditional heist, they decide to literally take the entire bank with them by hijacking a mobile home that serves as a temporary bank branch. The ringleader, a clever and somewhat luckless criminal, leads his eccentric team through a series of misadventures and close calls as they try to outwit the authorities and pull off what they hope will be a lucrative, if not entirely well-thought-out, crime. The novel is a blend of humor and suspense, delivering a story where the heist itself becomes as unpredictable as the characters attempting it.

  21. 21. God Save The Mark by Donald E. Westlake

    The book is a comedic crime caper centered around a perpetually gullible man who finds himself the unexpected heir to a large sum of money. His naivety makes him a magnet for con artists and criminals, leading him into a series of misadventures as he navigates a world filled with deceit and danger. Despite his susceptibility to being duped, he must learn to outwit the schemers who are after his inheritance, all the while questioning the legitimacy of his windfall and the intentions of those around him. The story combines humor with suspense, creating a satirical look at the lengths to which people will go for wealth.

  22. 22. The Hog Murders by William L. Deandrea

    "The Hog Murders" is a gripping murder mystery set in a small town plagued by a series of gruesome killings. As the body count rises, a determined detective and his team race against time to catch the sadistic killer, uncovering a web of secrets and deceit that shakes the community to its core. Filled with suspense and unexpected twists, this thrilling novel keeps readers on the edge of their seats until the shocking conclusion.

  23. 23. Motherless Brooklyn by Jonathan Lethem

    The novel follows Lionel Essrog, a detective with Tourette's Syndrome, as he navigates the rough streets of Brooklyn to solve the murder of his mentor and only friend, Frank Minna. Despite his condition, Lionel's obsessive mind proves to be a valuable asset in uncovering the truth about Frank's death, leading him through a maze of secrets, corruption, and betrayal within the Brooklyn underworld. The book is a compelling blend of mystery, humor, and an exploration of the human condition through the eyes of a uniquely gifted protagonist.

  24. 24. Eight Million Ways To Die by Lawrence Block

    In this gripping crime novel, a former cop turned private investigator, Matt Scudder, is hired to find the killer of a high-class call girl. As he delves deeper into the dark underbelly of New York City, Scudder becomes entangled in a web of deceit, corruption, and addiction. With his own demons haunting him, Scudder must navigate the dangerous streets and confront his own personal demons in order to bring justice to the victims and find redemption for himself.

  25. 25. Prizzi's Honor by Richard Condon

    The book revolves around Charley Partanna, a hitman for the Prizzi family, one of the most powerful crime syndicates in America. Charley's life becomes complicated when he falls in love with Irene Walker, a beautiful freelance assassin. Unbeknownst to him, Irene is also involved in swindling the Prizzis. As their romance deepens, Charley is torn between his loyalty to the family and his feelings for Irene, leading to a treacherous game of deceit, power, and honor that could cost him everything he holds dear.

Reading Statistics

Click the button below to see how many of these books you've read!

Download

If you're interested in downloading this list as a CSV file for use in a spreadsheet application, you can easily do so by clicking the button below. Please note that to ensure a manageable file size and faster download, the CSV will include details for only the first 500 books.

Download